Shower worthy thoughts

As my last blog post suggested, I’ve had moments of foul mood lately. Not openly explosively bad, just a bit testier than usual. Nor really any worse than those of anyone who hasn’t had a perfect life (hence everyone) The kind of cranky where other people won’t really notice, but I might be snappy with my husband. There could be any number of reasons why, from the stress of a move, to the incredibly insane heat in this new region of the country, to my anxiety over what’s happening next for me in my career. But because of Natan’s death, I think I’m more aware than before of my moods and their shifts. I’m a bit more careful with myself, in particular because I want to be fair to Samuel.

I was hoping for more relaxation and relief in the month of July. July was a great month, in many ways, but instead of reflection, it was full of action and change. I feel like we’ve just landed after catapulting out of the Midwest. In trying to figure out where my brain is, I’m having many expected thoughts that fit, but one that’s really strange: Josie Duggar keeps popping into my mind.

What on earth does Josie Duggar have to do with me? Nothing other than being born at the same gestation as Natan. Nothing other than that her birth gobsmacked me at an incredibly awkward moment. I was teaching a course in the fall in which we’d looked at the historical development of modern media culture. It was the last day of class and my lesson plan for the day was simple: pull up People Magazine online on the screen in front of the students and analyze what was there.

What happened was almost too strange to be true. I typed in the URL and saw, DUGGAR DAUGHTER BORN AT 25 WEEKS, 6 DAYS! or some such phrase pop up in front of my eyes, in front of 30-odd undergraduates. Fabulous. What did I do? Kept going. Fortunately, no one in class even seemed to want to touch that, and instead focused on a story about KStew and RPat or something on the sidebar. When class ended, I went back to my office and laughed. Really, really hard. And then chatted with a fellow blogger.

The universe didn’t count on my morbid sense of humor when it decided to royally screw me. Either that or it shares in my sickness.

I am not jealous of the Duggars. I am thankful beyond belief that Josie and Michelle Duggar are okay. In that moment, Michelle Duggar was just another mom and woman to me, and I did not want to imagine her burying that baby. I didn’t want to know about another dead baby at all, and I also didn’t want to think about Josie being ripped from her mom’s uterus and attached to machines.

In the aftermath of their experience, I actually feel that Mr. and Mrs. Duggar have been gracious and humble in the print I’ve read. I don’t understand this 20th baby possibility, but that doesn’t really matter to my life.

So what’s bothering me? I think that no matter how much I come to peace with my experience, I’ll never completely get over the anger of being on the bad side of statistics. Nor will I ever fully accept that some people get their happier endings, like me, while other deserving, good people do not. Part of Natan’s legacy for me seems to be getting to know about an increasing number of couples who aren’t going to get that living son or daughter.

You can tell me “God has his reasons,” and that may very well be true. I can’t take that to mean that there’s divine reason that in any way approximates human reason. Because if I do, I can only conclude that I disagree with it. It’s wrong for children to die, and for parents to suffer through it. Yet it seems inevitable, to some degree. So maybe I’m supposed to get angry and that’s the reason—to push me to do something about reducing the inevitability. That’s even worse reasoning, honestly. I’m not particularly charmed by the idea of a pedantic God. Pedagogic, maybe.

I think that what annoys me about the Josie Duggar story has nothing to do with her at all. If she actually, as Jim Bob Duggar said recently, “will be caught up by the time she’s two,” then she’s really an exception for a 25 week, 6 day baby. She’s extraordinarily fortunate, as are her parents. Someone has to be in that very tiny percentage that will be fine, great even. There’s no reason it should not be Josie Duggar.

But what I don’t like about the story is how it perpetuates the myth that things always work out okay for good people. They do not. We just don’t talk about those people for whom they do not. Whatever happened to the Morrison sextuplets for example? Now, I understand why their parents did not want to remain in the spotlight—mourning the death of five babies and coping with one micro-preemie is not something anyone wants to do under the glare of the media.

When you go into labor or have to deliver before 28 weeks, the world more often works against you than for you. It’s wonderful and heartwarming to hear about babies who will “catch up” but most will not. I’m not quoting statistics here because it keeps changing and is complexly contingent. Josie Duggar in part survived when Natan did not because three years passed between them, and because doctors made the decision to deliver, rather than being forced to. Unless things have changed tremendously though, she was an exception. I don’t want people to think any differently because that just makes those of us who got unlucky more freakish than we were before.

4 responses to “Shower worthy thoughts

  1. You actually touched on one of the reasons I do have a problem with the Duggers. It is always presented as though their faith in God and the fact that they are “good people” saved them from worse fates. But, I was a good person too.

    Society loves the happy ending. The thing I have learned with baby death is that it is so awful and sad and tragic that, literally, people cannot handle it. We truly are the lepers of modern society.

  2. This feeling you describe regarding Josie really resonates with me. Years out from my loss, subsequent baby out of diapers, husband even vasectomied (thereby putting a definitive end to all that woeful pregnancy/baby stuff) most days I’m hopeful and/or freaking out about a whole different set of concerns than a few years back. But stories of people beating huge medical odds always leave me cold now. For these stories to be heartwarming, you must believe that survival always = winning. And I don’t believe that anymore. I’ve seen too much to just blithely buy that line.

  3. You know, I was thinking about her recently too. And yes, the false impression thing bothers me too. But when I was thinking back on when she was first born, I remember a whole other set of concerns I had. Besides not wanting her to die for the simple reason that I didn’t want anyone’s baby to die, I remember also thinking that I hoped her parents wouldn’t end up in my “clubhouse,” wouldn’t end up being the media go-to people for baby death. I am, I think, nowhere nearly as generous as you are. I remember being conflicted at the time thinking about what happens if they do end up becoming baby lost parents, and I remember knowing that I wasn’t generous enough to just emphasize– I couldn’t leave their worldview, the things I knew they’ve said before (about their children being essentially deserved by their righteousness) outside of the bubble of this new would-be reality. It was confusing to me to think through all that, and I was very conflicted about it at the time. Now I think I accept the conflict, and I accept that it is not entirely resolved for me, but also, I think, that those feelings I had then are understandable.

  4. Great post. I think you articulate your thoughts on this well. I had many of my own conflicting thoughts about this, but ultimately do not want to see any parent lose their baby, even if I am not a fan of said parent. That said, I wish they would just stop.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s